| Teacher Supplies home >
Teacher Supplies News Center > Teachers leery of new standards
Teachers leery of new standards
Click
here to see our selection of Teacher Supplies.
 Special
education students may see biggest changes
School work:
Jacob Reiman (right) works on a class project with the help of teacher
Peggy Bloczynski in the fiifth grade at Osolo Elementary School.
Special education teachers, like those who work with Jacob, are
leery about new requirements under the No Child Left Behind Act.
Photo: Fred Flury / The Truth
ELKHART -- Tougher requirements on teachers are intended to guarantee
a highly qualified teacher in each classroom and better learning.
But special-education students' needs may be neglected as the new
standards are implemented, local experts warn.
They worry that school administrators will try to get around the
particularly tough requirements on special-education teachers by
mainstreaming special-education students from self-contained classes
into regular classrooms.
"It's not always in the best interest of the child to be in
the classroom," said Jeanna Salyer, teacher for the Clarion
alternative middle-school program in Goshen. "I'm afraid a
lot of kids will be caught in the middle.
Clarion, which operates from the Boys & Girls Club of Greater
Goshen, is a voluntary program that provides an alternative environment
for students who have difficulty functioning in a traditional school
environment.
"We'll probably have many students going to special education
for English going into regular classes, classroom sizes are going
to be bigger, they may not get the help they need, there'll be frustration
in general education teachers as to how to adjust the material."
According to the federally mandated No Child Left Behind Act, teachers
must be "highly qualified" with a state license and college
degree in each core subject they teach, for instance English, math,
reading or language arts, science, history, civics and government,
geography, economics, fine arts and foreign languages.
The problem is that special-education teachers must be highly qualified
in each of those subjects if they are the primary teacher. There's
no such requirement if they're teaching alongside a regular teacher.
Mary Beth Hamilton, director of the Elkhart County Special Education
Cooperative, said most regular teachers will meet the requirements
at the end of the school year, but that many local special-education
teachers won't be qualified by the new standards.
"We're OK within our cooperative with the exception of providing
direct instruction in self-contained classrooms," Hamilton
said.
ECSEC includes six school districts -- Goshen, Concord, Baugo,
Middlebury, Fairfield and Wa-Nee.
Hamilton didn't know how many local special-education teachers
aren't qualified, but said some districts are already mainstreaming
students.
She said she has received several e-mails from area teachers worried
about their special-education students being placed in regular classrooms
to avoid having "unqualified" teachers in pull-out sections.
"They'd be in hot water if they said that publicly,"
she said.
Some special-education students, such as Jacob Reiman in Osolo
Elementary (see related story), have taken general education classes
with success, as long as they follow certain core subjects as special
education.
At Memorial High School, it has been a positive experience to have
special-needs students in regular classrooms so far, said Mary Jo
Sartorius, director of special education at Elkhart Community Schools.
ISTEP scores for special-education students have gone up from 25
percent passing in 2003 to 33 percent in 2006, she said.
"We have kids passing ISTEP now that we couldn't even think
would take it 10 years ago, but there's a point where we have to
be realistic," Sartorius said. "Kids can make improvements
in general education. If we do this well, we can have some success
stories, but at Memorial, we still offer self-contained math classes."
In Elkhart Community Schools, about 2,300 students, or 17 percent,
receive some kind of special-education services, she said.
The deadline for meeting standards is the end of this school year,
but may be extended until 2007. If not, it would be almost impossible
for Elkhart schools to continue to offer self-contained classes
in seventh through 10th grade in the new year, Sartorius said.
On the other hand, it would be problematic to put students with
mental handicaps, autism, severe behavioral or emotional disabilities
into regular classrooms all the time.
"If it triggers behaviors; it's not good for anyone,"
she said. "It's very disruptive and could put others at risk.
It's not fair to special-education students to put them in a situation
like that. We have an obligation to keep children safe and we don't
want anyone to get hurt."
Sally Schleuter, who teaches emotionally disabled students, said
students in her class can't function in a general education setting
because they need smaller class sizes and more support.
"One of the benefits to these students is, being in self-contained
rooms, we can take care of them individually," she said. "There's
a lot less anxiety and more structure. And I know what their triggers
are. If there's a problem, I can attend to it right on the spot.
If you're one teacher with 20 students, that's just not feasible."
It all boils down to one question, said Salyer of Clarion.
"The issue is, is it in the best interest of students, or
will they be cheated out of what's best for them?"
Contact Gitte Laasby at glaasby@etruth.com.
http://www.etruth.com/News/Content.aspx?ID=370258&page=
This weeks top selling teaching supplies
Click here to see more classroom
supplies & decorations
Discuss teaching ideas, lesson plans, classroom
strategies
and more on our teacher
forum!
|
